SEASON 14, EPISODE 2, “BUBBLING UP” ANALYSIS



In the Season 14, Episode 2, “Bubbling Up”, the team met in the War Room to go over Carbon dating results of the wood found in last week’s episode in the Money Pit area at Borehole L.25-11. Craig Tester revealed that the date range of the wood was the following with probability percentages: 1759-1789 (29.7%), 1680-1684 (21.9%), 1733-1757 (17.7%), 1928-1953 (16.9%), 1791-1803 (9.2%). Dr. Ian Spooner stated he favored the 1680-1684 dating. Dr. Spooner then proceeded to use a portable XRF machine to analyze the artifact. He detected the following metals: Titanium (56.8%), Iron (32.6%), Copper (4.55%), Zinc (2.63 %), Lead (1.27%), Molydenum (.65%), and Niobium (.36%). He mentioned that this was unusually high lead content and had been in place for a long time and the lead was old. He said this was an exotic wood sample. High copper content may point to treasure in his opinion. He believes this wood was from a deposit in the Money Pit and was soaking up these metals.
ANALYSIS

The metals found from the portable XRF readings are indeed quite interesting. It appears that the metals Iron, Copper, Zinc, and Lead were the common base metals found in mining shafts in the 17th and 18th Century. The other metals Titanium, Molydenum, and Niobium and more modern discovered and probably not recognized at the time. The high lead levels could be from the assaying process where lead was used to process gold and silver out of rock deposits and veins. Why Dr. Spooner would favor the 1680-1684 dating of the wood is puzzling when a higher percentage is attributed to the 1759-1789 range. Although it appears that this activity could have stretched into multiple time periods. The notion that this evidence does not point to natural metals, continues to baffle this author. There is no evidence to suggest that these readings come from a treasure cache and more likely originate from natural metals that are found in the Mahone Bay area in this author’s opinion. Dr. Spooner has suggested in the past a dump truck of silver resides in the Money Pit area, but it has never been found. There is always a theoretical possibility that treasure exists on the island, and a hope for all involved. Although in this case, it appears there was a search for treasure instead of a deposit of it.
For this article and all of our information regarding the Oak Island Mystery, please visit www.theoakislandcompendium.com Look for weekly articles from this author regarding major discoveries and interesting information that is covered in Season 14 of “The Curse of Oak Island”. If you have a question or have a theory regarding the Oak Island Mystery you’d like to share, please send us an email at theoakislandcompendium@gmail.com
Good day from Daniel of the Compendium



